Thursday, September 20, 2012

50 Shades of Suck

This post could also be entitled: 50 Shades of Poor Writing.  Or E.L. James Repeats Herself for 528 Pages. 

Who are you people and WHY do you like this book???


I just don't understand it.  It's probably related to how I don't understand why everyone is obsessed with Lululemon or loves The Avengers or is devoted to Downton Abbey.  Clearly, I don't always like what society thinks I should.

And in most cases, I can see the appeal.  Lululemon is well made, high quality, comfortable (probably, I'm just guessing).  I'm not the biggest lover of comic book movies.  I'm probably not smart enough to truly enjoy Downton Abbey.  But 50 SHADES OF GREY?  Let's forget it's all about sex for a minute, I don't care about that.  I mean, do I want to read the book out loud to my parents or worse, my grandma?  No, absolutely not.  I don't even want to read that book out loud, period.  But I can get past that.  But there are other aspects of the book that I can't get past. 

First, the writing itself is POOR, at best.  SO FREAKING REPETITIVE!  If Ana says "oh my" one more time I might SCREAM.  Same goes for "clench", "mercurial", "delicious", "eyes hooded", etc.  And what's with the talking to her inner self-conscious or "inner goddess" - who does that?!


Second, it's BORING.  There is absolutely NO story line besides them having sex.  Don't get me wrong, I love a little bit of a love story.  But that can't be the ONLY PLOT LINE.  Katniss and Peeta were FAR from the sole plot going on.  Even Bella and Edward at least have all kinds of crazy vampire and werewolf stuff going on.  And yes, while Harry and Ginny lived happily ever after, first they had to take care of that minor problem of killing all the horcruxes and taking care of that Voldemort character. 

Third, umm, I'm confused - isn't this book EXACTLY like Twilight??!!!  Like I feel like the beginning of the book is so similar that there is a potential lawsuit on their hands.  Ana (aka Bella) - both pale, very KLUTZY / uncoordinated, innocent, don't know their own beauty, don't know their own effects on others, etc.  Meet Christian (aka Edward), who tries to stay away from her because he's "a danger" to her.  Then Ana (aka Bella) gets herself into a situation that she needs "rescuing" from, and lo and behold, Christian (aka Edward) saves her.  SERIOUSLY IT'S THE SAME.


I just don't understand why this book stands out to America more than cheap romance novels.  What makes it special?  Why is everyone SO obsessed?  I totally get that people think it's a "guilty little pleasure" like ice cream or coffee creamer.  But is it too much to ask for for SOMETHING TO ACTUALLY HAPPEN???? 

Sorry people, I don't think I'm going to make it through all 3 books.  I just can't take it.  End complete rant.  Sorry if you hate me now.

Who's read Fifty Shades of Grey?  What about the other two (Fifty Shades Darker and Fifty Shades Freed)?  Who loves the books and why?  Thoughts???

Comments (28)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I agree with all your points! Book totally blew! Will never read the other two either. I made myself finish the first one because I don't like to be a quitter.
My recent post Wordless Wednesday
mego @watchmegorun's avatar

mego @watchmegorun · 655 weeks ago

the book was written as a twilight fan fiction story at first (a way to make the bella and edward story racier). Then people loved it, the author changed it (only slightly) and got it published. I believe thats the only reason it's so popular...bc of its popularity with twilight fans first. I admit I got sucked into the first book hard, even with the sucky writing. I think it was more because it was a trainwreck and I kept thinking, "well what next?" I had to stop like three times in the second book because they were so goshdarn annoying (and repetitive) that they needed to be punched and bc Ana needs to grow a backbone. I borrowed the third book from my friend because I hate not finishing series and I got about 50 pages in and have been stuck there for well over a month. I just can't do it. I am fine with reading smut, but this is just stupid, repetitive, annoying and by the third book? the "steamy" scenes are ridiculous as well. It's like "we get it, they have sex a lot, what else?" I'm just waiting and hoping for a book that comes along that is much better written and also intellectually stimulating with a sexual undertone. It can totally be done!
BAHAHAHA! I went on this same rant after a friend convinced me I *had* to read it, and I made it about halfway. I want those hours of my life back!!!! Even if you're able to get past what is perhaps the worst writing I've read since one of the football players was forced to take creative writing in eleventh grade, then you are stuck dealing with a character with whom I cannot identify. She's a flipping victim. Is this what we want society to idolize, to emulate? It's bad enough women love, adore, and want to be like so many "reality" stars (I.e. vapid, materialistic, slutty, and drunk), but at least the RH of whichever region always FIGHT their own battles! I cannot abide by terrible writing, but terrible writing with such a despicable main character makes me feel like I need to take a toothbrush to my brain to scrub off the residual stupidity.
Pause. Are you indicating that you liked the Twilight books better than 50 Shades of Gray? I've never read 50 Shades, but I can't imagine a book that is equivalent to the Twilight series in the why-in-the-world-doesn't-everyone-realize-it-stinks factor.
My recent post I’m a Believer!
I think people like 50 Shades of Grey because they enjoy being a part of something. They like the hype and talking about it with friends. And I can't blame them, I understand. At the same time from the little I've read of the book it is not very good, and honestly if you think that is kinky then you are so innocent (in my humble opinion). But, there are worse things people could do, and I'm glad if someone enjoys themselves. I just wish I could write a crap book and make a ton of money off of it :)
1 reply · active 655 weeks ago
This makes me love you even more! I refuse to read the book, I KNOW won't like it and I'm not even willing to give it a chance. And this just further proves my feelings, so I enjoyed your rant :)
1 reply · active 655 weeks ago
I think you and I have the same taste in books! Except I haven't succumbed to the 50 Shades pressure. I have NO desire to read it. None. I heard early on that it was poorly written. If I want smut, I'll go find some Harlequin Romance.

Also, 50 Shades started out as Twilight fan fiction. That is why it resembles the original so much. I don't know how they deal with the fan fiction phenomenon as far as copyright infringement etc. I don't think Twilight was particularly well-written. The characters were shallow and undeveloped. But I agree, at least there is a plot. I think that Hunger Games was at a different level than Twilight. Katniss is a fantastic character!

I would love to see your list of books you've read. Are you on Goodreads?
My recent post Pre-race checklist
1 reply · active 655 weeks ago
I WAS KINDA SORTA IN BLOGLOVE WITH YOU ALREADY AND YOU JUST CLENCHED IT WITH YOUR MERCURIAL INNER GODDESS. ; )

I hate these books, and I'm a fan of the genre. But poorly written words are never sexy. Never.

As to the fanfic aspect, I heard an interview with the author of Twilight (whose name my brain refuses to recall because Twilight is God Awful too) and she considers it a compliment. Which I thought was very gracious of her. I consider it garbage.

So now we have to be besties, whether you like it or not.
3 replies · active 655 weeks ago
Bahahahaaha. Best post ever?!?! Quite possibly. It definitely made me laugh.

Read the first 2 books. As poor as the writing quality was, the title of the second book held some sort of promise for plot, but then didn't deliver. Just more sex. Worst writing ever. I cannot even fathom bothering to read the 3rd book - I just can't.

I am waiting for a stats page to show up - how many times her inner goddess does gymnast moves, how many times she bites her lips, how many times the word mercurial appears....
1 reply · active 655 weeks ago
I read a sample on my Nook and even that was hard to get through. But I totally get the whole idea of being a part of a group and reading it to have something fun to talk about.
Oh my. I want to know what woman exsists that likes sex THAT much?!?! AND what guy gets THAT turned on by biting your bottom lip?!?!
I think people are overly interested in anything that contains sex. The book has such blatent sex, practically porn and has been accepted as "okay" for women to read without having to hide it.
I get annoyed enough reading through all my emails, why would I want to read that in a book...? Over and over and over!
Love the posters, almost as good as the running Ryan Gosling posters.
yep. read all 3. and i read them quickly. maybe read/scan is a better word for it. the writing is AWFUL. and the story is basically fan fiction of twilight-so yes, it is identical. i’ve heard the original names were edward and bella because fan fiction is your own story based on the books you are a fan of-or something like that. not going to lie-totally enjoyed the sex stuff. completely unrealistic-but highly entertaining. much prefer other books to these but had to know what the hype was about. :)
My recent post Baywatch Running and a WINNER!
1 reply · active 655 weeks ago
I'm about to start the last one, just b.c I usually have to finish everything I start. Yep, horribly written (same as Twilight) but I like mindless entertainment every once in awhile and think these books fit the bill. Kinda like watching the Kardashians.
BTW, this reviewer on Goodreads will CRACK YOU UP. http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/340987215?au...
My recent post Ten Running Questions
2 replies · active 655 weeks ago
love this post.
I read 5 pages...that was more than enough
I dont get it either ...
My recent post And the Endorphine Warrior Traning Bracelet goes to.....
Same story.....supposed a must read. Didn't make it past first chapter. Done! Not going to happen.
P.S. You make me laugh.
i haven't read it. haven't really looked into it yet to see if i would even want to, but from the few comments i've heard about i don't think it'll be on my list.

lululemon - overpriced. shorts are shorts and capris are capris. unless their clothes were going to reduce my body fat by 10%, i won't be buying them.

downton abbey - i like the show, but not in a hurry to finish it on netflix. i mean i'll sit down and watch a marathon of pretty little liars or gossip girl, shows where my brain power is, ha.
My recent post keep your chin up
Michelle H.'s avatar

Michelle H. · 654 weeks ago

It makes me so angry that people are STILL buying this book. Aren't there a sh*t ton of them out there?? I wish people would just borrow a copy from one of the millions out there rather than perpetuate the sales of this absolute crap. I totally agree with your take on it. I had more fun reading the one & two star reviews on Amazon than I did reading and not finishing the first book. Seriously, check out some of the bad reviews. :)
Right there with you. I won't read it because if I want to read erotica, there's SO MUCH BETTER WRITING OUT THERE and if I want mindless brain candy there is... so much better writing out there!!!
My recent post Morning motivation

Post a new comment

Comments by